Stepping into the tough-to-fill shoes of Walter Matthau, Billy Bob Thornton plays the liquor-swilling, foulmouthed Morris Buttermaker, who has agreed to coach a Little League team for the paycheck. Unfortunately for him, his assembled team consists of the league’s most inept outcasts. Gradually, however, Buttermaker’s determination wins out, to the point where he recruits an ex-girlfriend’s gifted daughter, Amanda Whurlitzer (Sammi Kane Kraft), to step onto the pitcher’s mound.

The team is complete when local bad boy Kelly Leak (Jeffrey Davies) lends his overflowing talent to the cause. Soon, the Bears are climbing their way to the top of the standings, resulting in a championship showdown with the Yankees, who are managed by the ridiculously pompous Coach Bullock (Greg Kinnear).